There is a new comment on the post "More on Shane Clancy and Dr Michael Corry".
http://seroxatsecrets.wordpress.com/2009/10/21/more-on-shane-clancy-and-dr-michael-corry/
Author: anon
Comment:
http://wellbeingfoundation.com/news1.html
Psych boss gears up to persecute Michael Corry
A ’senior psychiatrist’, UCC Professor Timothy ‘Ted’ Dinan, has laid a complaint against Dr Michael Corry at the Medical Council.
In a letter to the Council’s Fitness to Practice Committee, Dinan said Dr Corry had made comments about a tragedy "without regard for the distress" caused to the families; had "made allegations regarding the competence" of a colleague [by suggesting a colleague treated a patient that rendered him homicidal and suicidal]; "made statements regarding a diagnosis without ever seeing the patient"; and made "statements regarding the pharmacology of antidepressants".
The professor has made previous attempts to chill debate on the mental health services and on the dangers, efficacy or otherwise of the treatments his profession holds dear, in particular the use of SSRIs and SNRIs to treat depression and other complaints.
The professor has close relations with several of the makers of the drugs he espouses and defends, and whose critics he is trying to silence. A statement of disclosure related to a course he has taught says: "Dr Dinan has received honoraria [cash payments] from and is a member of the speakers board and advisory board for Lilly, Pfizer, Lundbeck, and Organon." (Reference here)
The professor’s Cork Neuroscience Group is funded by, among others, the Wellcome Trust (which funds biomedical research) and GlaxoSmithKline, which itself resulted from two mergers. The first merger saw Burroughs Wellcome, founder of the Wellcome Trust, join with Glaxo plc, to form GlaxoWellcome. This later fused with SmithKline Beecham to create GSK, second largest drug company in the world and manufacturer of Seroxat/Paxil.
He speaks at meetings which advocate the view that depression is underdiagnosed in Ireland by as much as 75% and that SSRIs are an essential treatment. For an example, see here
Signing himself as Timothy Dinan, MD, PhD, FRCPsych, FRCPI, Professor of Psychiatry, University College Cork, the academic was one of six professors of psychiatry who penned a letter published in the Irish Times on 16 November 2006 demanding the resignation of the then Minister for Mental Health, Tim O’Malley, for two reasons.
One, O’Malley had dared to suggest that many everyday difficulties of life were being mis-labeled as ‘clinical depression’. Secondly, he had dared to suggest, with good reason, that the alleged benefits of medications used to treat mental illness cannot be proven scientifically in the way that other medications can. Both suggestions are cardinal sins for those who rule the world of psychiatry, and whose word is law among the students they teach.
Interestingly, the ’six professors letter’ drew a ferocious wave of disagreement, from former patients, from psychiatrists and GPs, from nurses, and from senior sociologists who have been studying the the use of psychiatric medications and such ‘therapies’ as electro-shock for many years.
Among the ’senior psychiatrists’ who disagreed with the six ruling professors was a former professor, perhaps the most distinguished professor of psychiatry this country has produced, Professor Emeritus Dr Ivor Browne.
Clearly, the response to that intervention has not blunted the desire of at least one of their number to chill debate and silence critics of institutional psychiatry and bad medicine.
In this latest attempt, the most chilling part of the complaint is that Corry made "statements regarding the pharmacology of antidepressants". If such a complaint was upheld as valid, neither Dr Corry nor any other doctor registered with the Irish Medical Council could ever again ‘make a statement’ on the action of a drug such as Seroxat or Lexapro — or, by extension, of any drug.
For the full report by the Sunday Tribune on the complaint against Michael Corry, see the right-hand column or go here
For the debate stirred up by Minister O’Malley’s remarks in 2006, see here
http://wellbeingfoundation.com/debate.html
See all comments on this post here:
http://seroxatsecrets.wordpress.com/2009/10/21/more-on-shane-clancy-and-dr-michael-corry/#comments